The City Council met regarding a decision on multi citizen appeal of  the Planning and Zoning Board approval of a site plan to allow construction of a two-story place of public assembly with a technical deviation for the Chabad of East Boca located at 770 East Palmetto Park Rd.

 

After four hours of listening to legal argument, cross examination, and rebuttal, one realizes that this matter will not be resolved in the political arena….

One commentator, a very educated gentleman, said that words like museum, exhibit hall, place of assembly….what difference does it make….His comment eluded that the entire evening was not really about the words but about something else; prejudice…

Even if that were the case, the measurement to judge any project can only be evaluated by words and the use of the words contained within the city code. Objective words and their plain meaning must be followed if there is to be ‘order’ versus ‘chaos’…..

Lawyers representing the appellants made compelling argument that there were not all the appropriate facts to make a fully informed decision.

Representative for the applicant did little to address the crucial issue; the issue leading to the horns of a dilemma.   The dilemma is framed as follows; to wit: Museum versus Exhibit Hall.  If a museum then it is not a permitted use; if an exhibit hall than there is not enough parking spaces for the permitted use.

From there, all sides offered numerous explanations, insights and intentions. These differences will perhaps never be agreed upon in the political arena but seem destined to the circuit court.

To listen to the city attorney in her summary, she justified the city posture by rationalizing differential treatment and application. ‘Justifiable’ was her chosen word coupled with a long winded attempt to justify ‘justifiable’.  That is perhaps the issue to take to circuit court.

So the outcome of the evening was as follows:

A motion made to uphold the P & Z Board decision by Deputy Mayor Weinroth; seconded by Councilman Mullaugh. Discussion ensued and the vote called….

Results:

Mayor Haynie – Yes

Deputy Mayor Weinroth – Yes

Councilman Mullaugh – Yes

Councilman Rodgers – Yes

Councilman Singer – Yes

Regardless of this outcome, the argument probably does not end here.