Boca’s Chamber of Commerce; A Misguided Mission

2

According to the Boca Raton Chamber of Commerce’s President, Troy McLellan, of all the needed critical items to enhance economic development in our city and its surrounds, the local government’s decision process concerning the “Wildflower” property at the failed intersection of Palmetto Park Rd. and NE 5th Ave is of critical importance.

Really????

Mr. McLellan, in two recently published articles, has decided to engage Chamber members in the controversial issue of what should be the outcome for this City- owned waterfront site. Perhaps, in all the matters that might benefit economic development and attract new corporate relocation, he sees as a critical need for another venue to host the endless stream of breakfasts, lunches, dinners and social engagements which dominate the activities of this Chamber.

In the April – June issue of the Chamber’s publication, “Connection”, a stern looking Mr. McLellan states that the Chamber’s mission is to “actively develop and promote policy positions on critical issues impacting the business community…” Specifically listed as one of these ‘critical issues’ is to “….monetize the City-owned former “Wildflower” property to receive a tax payer return on investment…”; a clearly dubious statement based upon a misrepresentation to the audience he solicits for support.

In a recent e-mail message (see attachment below), he, in a more cordial picture portrayal, again solicits the help of Chamber Members and Community Stakeholders to advance the critical issue of monetizing the “Wildflower” site. As support for this request he states that “In 2012, the property was designated to include a free standing restaurant under a land lease arrangement; an absolute misrepresentation of the historical facts on the public record.

The Historical Fact….

At the time of purchase, this acquisition was justified by the then City Council as a place for the enjoyment of the many residents who would use the location for recreational purposes.   There is no public record suggesting that the purchase was intended for a land lease to a private commercial restaurateur, the Hillstone group or any other restaurant. Let me repeat…there is no public record that has been found supporting the assertion that the site was purchased for commercial development.

What has happened over the years is that the City Council has redirected the conversation suggesting that a standalone restaurant was the intended use for the property. The Council has met great push back from the residents but has continued to act over the objection of many and in light of various surveys resulting in the unequivocal support for a green space containing activities including a food element for families to take advantage of Boca Raton’s waterfront.

Mr. McLellan goes on to misstate the facts by asserting that the downtown would be “energized” by a “premier waterfront restaurant”…and help create a sense of place in our emerging downtown. His statement suggests that, at this time, there is no alternative Boca Raton waterfront restaurant, an incorrect assertion; to wit: The Waterstone.

To the issue of creating a sense of place, one need only look at the concrete jungle that has become the essence of our emerging downtown; a direct result of the attitude that business and developer interests take priority over the quality of life that has branded Boca Raton as the desirable destination it is. This attitude is evidenced in many ways….

With some 2500 new apartment units either already out of the ground or coming in the near future, there has been no effort by the city leaders to address the lack of urban active green space to enhance the living experience of these newly arriving ‘downtowners’.   The Wildflower site offers that possibility; a mere restaurant does nothing to afford the urban experience suggested in the justifications at the time of purchase. There is no doubt as to the truth of this statement.

Mr. McLellan ends with a call to action for the Chamber members to contact the City Council in a show of support to:

  1. a) Generate a positive financial gain for the city;
  2. b) Enhance our downtown; and
  3. c) Maintain our quality of life.

What Are The Goals?

These goals are not inconsistent with the idea of an active urban green space for the enjoyment of all the residents, not just the privileged few who can afford the expensive dining experience which may result from the current negotiations between the city and the private sector.

BocaWatch suggests that the Chamber stick to the business of true economic development and attracting new corporate interests to Boca Raton.

In a recent ‘Coffee and Conversation’ hosted by Councilman Scott Singer, a high ranking member of the Chamber publically stated that new commercial properties within the City may be decades away.

For an City that touts as its objective the notion of being a place to ‘live, work and play’, the place to ‘live’ has advanced to the point of congestion but the idea of offering a place to ‘work’ is clearly missing. The idea of providing a place to ‘play’ is being drowned out by the Chamber’s clamor to have a restaurant on the only public waterfront site in or near the downtown available for this purpose….

Oh my, perhaps overlooked is the possibility that this restaurant does offer employment but for the very few, just as it also offers the few, ‘play’ activities at the most significant waterfront site in our city for all residents to enjoy.

In baseball, batting .333 gets you a major league contract; in politics this represents a failing grade.

Thank you Mr. McLellan for this opportunity for me to argue to the residents that ‘quality of life’ and ‘enhancing our downtown’ is by no means within the scope of the Chamber’s position.

To Our Readers….

BocaWatch encourages you to contact the Mayor and City Council members and express your feelings concerning the eventual use of the ‘Wildflower’ site; to wit an extensive standalone restaurant or an active, recreational, urban green space.

BocaWatch also encourages that this item be put on the ballot as a referendum question in the March, 2017 elections to, once and for all, identify the will of the people and direct the public servants to implement that will.

Mayor Susan Haynie – shaynie@ci.boca-raton.fl.us
Deputy Mayor Robert Weinroth – rweinroth@ci.boca-raton.fl.us
Councilman Mike Mullaugh – mmullaugh@ci.boca-raton.fl.us
CRA Chair,Councilman Scott Singer – ssinger@ci.boca-raton.fl.us
Jeremy Rodgers – jrodgers@ci.boca-raton.fl.us

Al Zucaro, Publisher


 

Chamber of Commerce letter noted above

 

troy ltr

 

Previous articleAn Open Letter To The Boca Raton City Council
Next articleBeware of Unintended Consequences
Alfred Zucaro has resided in Palm Beach County since 1982 and has been a resident of Boca Raton since 2008. A graduate of Fordham University, he holds a Magna Cum Laude degree in Economics. Mr. Zucaro attended Nova University receiving a Juris Doctorate Law Degree in 1986. He is a member in good standing with the Florida Bar, practicing in the area of Immigration Law for the majority of his career. Currently he is manager/member of Palm Beach Investment and Finance LLC, a USCIS approved regional center identifying foreign investment leading to permanent resident status. Mr. Zucaro served as a City Commissioner in West Palm Beach from 1995 to 2002 and as the President of the City Commission in 2000/2001. He has also been a member of and/or served on the Economic Council, the Business Development Board, the Film and Television Commission, the Tourist Development Council, the Workforce Alliance and the Palm Beach International Film Festival. Of particular interest is his founding of the World Trade Center Palm Beach, an organization that focuses on international economic development. Married to Yvonne Boice, they are avid world travelers having visited 6 continents and dozens of countries since their 2008 nuptials.

2 COMMENTS

  1. Thank you Boca Watch for pointing out the obvious. The Chamber of Commerce supports a restaurant on the last remaining public space that can be used by all people, a walkable draw from downtown to water’s edge.

    Where was Mr McLellan and “his” Chamber when Palmetto Promenade was being considered? There are 900 street side, lineal feet of potential small business space that should and would have been a draw to the East end of downtown, an enticement to walk and shop. No, not now. Think about those jobs and the potential high end business opportunities to make Boca’s downtown more special. No, not now, just a token offering.

    With a restaurant on the property, the Chamber of Commerce looses a location to host civic events as does Rotary and other organizations where the community can meet in a walkable waterside setting. Can’t do that at the pavilion at the end of Palmetto.

    And the capper. Mayor Welchel stated on the very night the City Council made the decision to purchase the land that it was for those that don’t have a boat and cannot afford to live on the water. Not with a restaurant. Where does the Chamber of Commerce get off making decisions for the citizens that own the property and on such a weak basis. Remember, a hamburger, fries, a glass of beer or wine and a 20% tip = $34.00. A dinner for two with salad, main course and desert = $118. And, the view is not that hot = backyards of homes vs a fabulous view of Lake Boca Raton from Waterstone either on the water or at the top. The “boys” at the chamber and on City Council want a watering hole for themselves at the expense of the majority of residents who can’t afford the price for such food.

    There is no evidence of a mandate that the property be used for a restaurant. Let the people vote for what they want, don’t let a “FEW” make a lasting decision for the many.

  2. Sent this email to the Council on 4/12
    –No restaurant!!!!!! There is no public record indicating the Wildflower property was intended for commercial use. Just the opposite.

    –Council lovefest with the BR CoC and developers. With more hotels, high rise (with a prized developer’s variance) condos coming on already traffic-choked streets, BR is rapidly becoming a place that creates jobs for poolboys, waiters, room cleaners, busboys, cooks, sous chefs, uber drivers, burger flippers and limo drivers, to name a few of the service industry jobs being created. You’re creating two Boca’s–one for the rich and one for the non-politically-connected middle and working class.

    –If we wanted to live in the congestion of Miami or Ft Lauderdale, we would have moved there. “Welcome to Ft. Bocadale!”

    Respectfully and anxiously awaiting the next city elections,

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here