The City Council met regarding a decision on multi citizen appeal of the Planning and Zoning Board approval of a site plan to allow construction of a two-story place of public assembly with a technical deviation for the Chabad of East Boca located at 770 East Palmetto Park Rd.
After four hours of listening to legal argument, cross examination, and rebuttal, one realizes that this matter will not be resolved in the political arena….
One commentator, a very educated gentleman, said that words like museum, exhibit hall, place of assembly….what difference does it make….His comment eluded that the entire evening was not really about the words but about something else; prejudice…
Even if that were the case, the measurement to judge any project can only be evaluated by words and the use of the words contained within the city code. Objective words and their plain meaning must be followed if there is to be ‘order’ versus ‘chaos’…..
Lawyers representing the appellants made compelling argument that there were not all the appropriate facts to make a fully informed decision.
Representative for the applicant did little to address the crucial issue; the issue leading to the horns of a dilemma. The dilemma is framed as follows; to wit: Museum versus Exhibit Hall. If a museum then it is not a permitted use; if an exhibit hall than there is not enough parking spaces for the permitted use.
From there, all sides offered numerous explanations, insights and intentions. These differences will perhaps never be agreed upon in the political arena but seem destined to the circuit court.
To listen to the city attorney in her summary, she justified the city posture by rationalizing differential treatment and application. ‘Justifiable’ was her chosen word coupled with a long winded attempt to justify ‘justifiable’. That is perhaps the issue to take to circuit court.
So the outcome of the evening was as follows:
A motion made to uphold the P & Z Board decision by Deputy Mayor Weinroth; seconded by Councilman Mullaugh. Discussion ensued and the vote called….
Results:
Mayor Haynie – Yes
Deputy Mayor Weinroth – Yes
Councilman Mullaugh – Yes
Councilman Rodgers – Yes
Councilman Singer – Yes
Regardless of this outcome, the argument probably does not end here.





Mr. Zucaro,
Boca Watch was supposed to be a forum where issues are reported, but it has become an editorial blog. YOUR editorial blog. That’s fine, but please do not advertise BocaWatch as being impartial.
Your “report” on the City Council meeting is anything but impartial. It has a clear undercurrent of anger and it is not a report, it is an opinion-laced editorial.
I was there at the meeting, the entire 5 1/2 hours of it. In my opinion – OPINION – the appellants’ arguments relied on semantic games and the invention of technicalities dependent on those semantics.
Those, at best, specious arguments were summarily refuted point by point by Mr. George Brown, assistant City Manager. Do you think Mr. Brown is in the tank for Chabad?
May I suggest that instead of ginning up hate and anger, you and your gang take some of the hundreds of thousands of dollars required of you to sue the city at great expense to our city too – and lose again – and use it for outreach to your neighbors instead of vain attempts to reject them.
We’ve been there before, Mr. Zuccaro. Never Again.
Never Again.
Dear Mr. Birman, BocaWatch has always and continues to extend an invitation to you and all readers to submit articles to our blog for publication. We welcome your opinion. Please write [email protected]
When will this stop? What happened to the East Boca I knew and loved with all its restrictions on size, signage, lighting, parking, etc? I’m all for moving forward, but take a look sometime. Christmas lights in July decorating/advertising businesses on Federal, cheesy to say the least. Don’t get me started about the looming traffic congestion – we are not and never will be a walking urban center. Seriously…let’s walk to the store in 95 degree heat and carry an umbrella because it might pour on the way home. And why have ordinances if they are just going to grant variances for everyone? Change the ordinance then… Time will tell – looks like there will be a shift back to the west soon.
The pristine, resort, beachside community on the barrier island of Boca Raton is being railroaded into acceptance of this obvious deviation of the style and size of new construction with the approval of this monstrous project. In order to win their approval, the Chabad leaders and their supporters used the anti-semitism card in order to create a cause celebre.
Since I live on this island and enjoy the beach frequently, I am not looking forward to this large, cement structure that features a windlow-less, institutional-style appearance, with no room for tropical landscaping or other characteristics familiar with this area, along with the traffic that will be generated by pedestrians and vehicles visiting this site.
Enhanced artistic renderings were used in order to garner the approval of zoning and other committees and ultimately the city council. Clever legal counsel manipulated language about building codes and variances to their advantage.
What was supposed to be a basic place of worship for the Chabad followers, was annexed with a museum, cafe and other amenities which is way too large for the size of this property that once housed a residence and a restaurant.
I hope that this projected structure does not go forward as planned. It will be destructive to this community and our way of life, which has supported the city of Boca Raton from its earliest history.
What I don’t understand about the approval of the “technical deviations” for the Chabad is why they were approved.
If I wanted to make a change to my house that wasn’t specifically to code, I believe I’d need at a minimum tacit approval from my immediate neighbors in addition to city approval. I’ve not met one resident in the immediate vicinity of 770 East Palmetto Park Road that is not against the deviations approved by the city.
Can someone help me understand that?
I’d like to clearly state that this is not about anti Semitism or fear of a “different culture.” I grew up in Flatbush Brooklyn and went to High School about 5 blocks from the “headquarters” at 770 Eastern Parkway in Crown Heights.
The Museum is not a “permitted use” so the rhetoric about it being a Chabad and that is why people are against it is not true.
The Boca “Symphony or the Historical Society” would not be able to build museums on that location.
The “fervor of the residents” was also in play when the Meridian Building on Palmetto and A1A was held up for five years. We care about our community and the codes that were designed to protect it.
If the Rabbi and his congregants say they want to be good neighbors then why are they not building it to code or negotiating with the community.
I just don’t understand!
Now that the dust has temporarily (and I do mean temporarily) settled down following last week’s city council meeting to hear various appeals against the over development of the lot at 770 E Palmetto I felt compelled to communicate directly with Mitch Kirschner (attorney for the applicant). I wrote to him as follows:
Dear Mr. Kirschner,
At the city council meeting last week you made the sweeping suggestion that those of us who are plaintiffs in the various appeals against the proposal for 770 E. Palmetto Park are somehow anti-Semitic. May I remind you sir that you were under oath at the time. Please take the time to answer the following:
1. Why did you think it was necessary to use this well-worn tactic to vilify us?
2. On what factual grounds did you make this slanderous assertion?
3. What do you know about my work in Israel during the period I lived there?
4. What do you know about my pro-bono work on behalf of the Sephardic Angels of NYC?
5. What do you know about my wife’s 10 year association with the Kabbalah center in west Boca?
6. What do you know about her tireless efforts to help that organization raise funds for their current facility?
7. Are you able to calculate the financial impact of your accusation on our respective businesses?
I demand immediate answers to these questions as well as an unconditional apology. In the meantime I will be forwarding this to the Florida Bar in the hope that you will be sanctioned.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Ian MacDougall
561.212.8793
I have not heard from Mr. Kirschner. This could be for a number of reasons:
– he doesn’t check his email
– he is unable to justify his inflammatory accusation
– he is consulting with his attorney
Your guess is as good as mine.